One Last Prompt Download
← Blog

Do app blockers work?

Zsolt Csizmadia, founder · · 3 min read

I tried several. After twenty minutes I turned them off. So before building my own, I read what has been measured.

The short answer is yes, with two large “buts”. Here is what each study found, and what it cannot tell you.

Limits you set in advance work

The strongest evidence comes from economists. In a randomized experiment, people were given the option to set limits on their own future screen time.1 Those who could set limits used their phones substantially less. The authors take this as a sign of a self-control problem: if you used your phone exactly as much as you wanted, a limit would change nothing.

Two more results from that paper stay with me. People were only partly aware of their own self-control problem, so they expected to need a limit less than they did. And in the authors’ model, self-control problems account for 31% of social media use.

A hard block works, for those who keep it

A trial from 2025 went further.2 467 iPhone users were asked to install an app that cut off all mobile internet on the phone for two weeks. Daily screen time fell from 314 minutes to 161. Well-being, mental health and the ability to hold attention improved, and 91% of the participants got better on at least one of the three.

The same paper has the first “but”. Only 119 people, about a quarter, kept the block on as they were asked to. This was a study they had signed up for, and three out of four still did not keep it.

Three out of four people did not keep the hard block, in a study they had signed up for.

Blocking alone wears off

The second “but” comes from a review of digital self-control tools, published in 2023.3 I could not open the paper itself, so I rely on the summary by the authors’ own research group. They write that today’s tools lean on blocking and removing, that this may reduce use in the short term, and that it does not hold in the long term because it does not help people form a new habit. They also note that most evaluations last about three weeks, rarely have a control group, and mostly study young, technical students.

The way out matters more than the wall

Economists who study commitment devices separate hard commitments from soft ones.4 A hard commitment has a real penalty and no exit. A soft one only makes the exit cost something, and their review argues that soft commitments solve problems the hard ones do not.

A study of the app one sec shows what a soft one can do.5 The app puts a short delay and a way to back out in front of the apps you choose. In six weeks of data from 280 users, people closed the app again in 36% of their attempts, and they tried to open it 37% less often. A separate experiment with 500 people tested which part did the work. The option to back out had the strongest effect and the delay helped. The message on the screen did nothing. One of the authors made the app, and the paper says so.

What none of them measured

All of these studies are about social media or phone use in general. None is about work apps or AI tools, and none measured whether people recovered better from work. I have not found a study that did.

What I looked for

After reading this, I stopped looking for a stronger wall. I wanted four things.

Narrow. A few apps, in the evening only. An all-day block is the kind three out of four people gave up.

Decided in advance. The closing time is set once, in daylight, and cannot be edited while the lock is on.

An exit that costs something. The exit is not hidden and it is not impossible. It costs a wait and a written reason.

Somewhere for the thing I was about to do. This is where my own blockers failed. They closed the app and left me alone with the idea. Why that matters is in why work follows you to bed.

That list is what I built One Last Prompt around. How I got there is in my own story. I cannot tell you it works better than the tools in these studies. Nobody has measured it, me included.

“One more prompt” becomes one last prompt.

One Last Prompt is an iPhone app, and it is out now on the App Store.

Download on the App Store

Zsolt Csizmadia builds One Last Prompt.

Sources

  1. Hunt Allcott, Matthew Gentzkow and Lena Song, “Digital Addiction”, American Economic Review 112(7):2424–2463, 2022. aeaweb.org
  2. N. Castelo, K. Kushlev, A. F. Ward, M. Esterman and P. B. Reiner, “Blocking mobile internet on smartphones improves sustained attention, mental health, and subjective well-being”, PNAS Nexus 4(2):pgaf017, 2025. academic.oup.com
  3. A. Monge Roffarello and L. De Russis, “Achieving Digital Wellbeing Through Digital Self-Control Tools: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis”, ACM Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction 30(4), 2023. Read through the summary published by the authors’ research group. elite.polito.it
  4. G. Bryan, D. Karlan and S. Nelson, “Commitment Devices”, Annual Review of Economics 2:671–698, 2010. doi.org/10.1146/annurev.economics.102308.124324
  5. David J. Grüning, Frederik Riedel and Philipp Lorenz-Spreen, “Directing smartphone use through the self-nudge app one sec”, PNAS 120(8):e2213114120, 2023. doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2213114120